Aita for telling my sister that she knew what she was getting when she settled for my ex. My sister who I will call Noelle, fucked up in my opinion.

Aita for telling my sister that she knew what she was getting when she settled for my ex. But I didn’t fall for it.

Aita for telling my sister that she knew what she was getting when she settled for my ex It really broke my heart to watch her learn who he really was. We are 5 siblings, 2 sets of twins (50F-my sister (her twin passed in utero), 47M-me and my brother, 42F-my other two sisters). Wow, this blew up a lot. My fiance and sister didn't like my ex-gf because she was a "bully. 6 months later the affair was still going so I served my ex with divorce papers . For a little context, I'm (19m) dating my gf Emmy (19f) for 8 months now. I understand why parents do this because I did it myself. Expect for his mum. LOL I was thinking the same thing. Ok so I(f24) was on the phone with my sister(27) and we were talking about our Christmas gathering last year. Fuck. 3 When she didn't get the response/ results she wanted her attitude changed. Me and my dad had it out over it. When she got back The oldest is always trying to seek me out. I said the same thing to Ella but they didn't. Your daughter's "punishment" from your ex and his wife was totally undeserved, her reaction was totally reasonable given her age and the situation, so honestly, do something nice with her and tell her you know she's going through a lot and you've got her back. She said we're family though and she's our sister. My sister called me a few hours ago, and said she’s not playing any more games with Mom, and that tomorrow she’s waking up at 4am, and driving down here to demand her daughter back and if my mom doesn’t give her up she says she’ll get the police involved, get attorneys involved and do whatever it takes to be reunited with her daughter. I told her that she knew she was getting a cheat when she decided to date my sloppy seconds and he was no longer my problem. I have 4 kids, 23, 20, 16 and 13. Like. I am engaged and my sister is going to marry in about a month. No. AITA for telling my sister that she knew what she was getting when she settled for my ex? #reddit #redditstories #redditreadings #askreddit Jack's family have ceased their negative comments about my sister but she says that they're still pretty formal and distant towards her. Apr 13, 2025 · Update, Ida for telling my sister that she knew what she was getting when she settled for my ex. My mother tried playing peacekeeper for the family. My mom didn’t listen to my little sister. And while intellectually I knew that it wasn't my sister's fault but was my parents, and I did and do love her dearly, I harbored a lot of ill feeling toward my sister from the time of her birth when I was 12 yo. My sister once told her ex if he didn't straighten up she would send me down to pickup one of the nibblings. In the first week we moved in Fred started showing his true colors. My sister who I will call Noelle, fucked up in my opinion. I found out because my brother caught the two of them together. Ya, Jack will never forgive her for this. I cut her off immediately. She’s not speaking to any of us either. Cast Taken Off. The manipulative ones are hard to deal with. AITA for telling my sister that she knew what she was getting when she settled for my cast-off ex? ( self. They have told me how uncomfortable it makes them because they aren't allowed to correct it. Told her what my expectations were and to let me know what her plan is so I can move the money around. Brodi has been in my life for over 13 years, and over that time had helped through lots of breakups and a pregnancy that left me alone to care for my child. I told her she's not welcome on our family vacation with mom, she never would be and none of us want her there. It cost me a lot of legal fees but I got 50 50 custody of my son. But she was SEETHING the whole time because of Ruby’s dress. Despite trying to conceive for years and having no success with her husband every month, my sister (31F) felt like a supreme disappointment. I found out about my first just a few months before the first anniversary. Help keep the sub engaging! 308 Likes, TikTok video from Reddit Stories (@reddit_tts_stories): "AITA for telling my sister that she knew what she was getting when she settled for my cast-off ex? #fyp #redditstory #aita #offmychest #askreddit". At this point my dad was crying. But the other day she told me my mom was disgusting and ugly, that she had been a bad wife and mom and that was why dad chose her mom. We didn’t talk about it and that was ok. Otherwise she would have asked for replacements herself. My brother's wife found out she was expecting their first less than a month later. Tammy-Lynn and her husband had two kids together before she got sick. I feel like I'm being realistic about long-term solutions and budgeting. I think I might be an asshole for telling my wife to work more if she wants to support her sister financially. She laughed and said you can't upstage a bride. With time and by my late 20s, my resentment had faded toward my sister. I went NC with Tory and LC with my parents. We are taking about our biggest one. They gave me every excuse in the books , I had waited it out for the sake of my kids to see if my ex husband would stop . Ex- 1downing your home and calling it a starter home, implying 2 asking the price and bragging how hers costs more. Telling my mom what she was allowed and not allowed to do in his house. I refused. 1K comments. She yelled at me and my dad got pissed at me for upsetting her and "saying such a shitty thing" to her and taking his affair out on her. 7. I truly love him, and thankfully get along with most of his family. This concerns my oldest, I'll refer to her as 'Zara' We don't normally do big parties in our family after double digits (and 18th/21st), but Zara has been going through a bit of a difficult time so we decided to throw her a surprise party. " She may be getting exactly what she deserves, too. She then apologised if I felt her outfit was inappropriate. No wonder when she thought she was only the half sister, she was hurt. I told her to stop telling everyone he cheated on her since she forgave him. She is so disrespectful about my mom and has wished she could do stuff to her grave when she's really trying to piss me off. Apr 17, 2025 · "AITA for telling my sister nobody was surprised when her kid said he did not care she was alive or not?" I come from a big family. My sister is upset about her mom and has taken her anger out on me. The classy guy she left me for left her while she was dealing with cancer. She tried to get my blessing for them to be together. A month before our wedding, EX and her friends went to Miami for her bachelorette party. They’ve said they wanted to be “child free” since they met 4 years ago. She threw a tantrum and said that surely my parents had manipulated my grandmother to make me leave nothing for her. I asked if I could wear white to her wedding then and she shrugged and said 'if you think it'll help'. When I was proposed to I asked all my family when they would be available and chose my wedding date then that took around a 3-4 weeks during that time my sister and her boyfriend were having a fight and weren’t talking but I don’t know why, but once he proposed my sister asked that we have our wedding on the same day same venue and I have I have been estranged from my sister ever since she carried out an affair with my ex-fiance. This annoyed me, so I told her, you’re not 18. My sister and I had (and have) a good relationship even before she saw it fully. My sister was there but didn’t help as much as Brodi. EDIT - depending on what the ex-wife's motives are here, she may be like, "Dude! I just realized that SIL likely had this reaction because she also knew OP would likely not replace the food (want to bet she asked for help and got rejected or was told, "I will give you money if you watch my kid") so she already knew OP was going to be heartless about it. It wasn’t at all outrageous by Ruby’s standards so I don't believe that she wanted to outshine my sister. She wont tell you about how every single one of his adult children is an alcoholic with extreme trauma caused by him. My sister got married this past weekend. She had a beautiful outside, socially distanced wedding. Emmy was invited to the wedding despite the fact my sister doesn't like her because she would rather me be with an ex fling of mine. " That's why I didn't say anything. That should change. We'd give anything for him to have met them. Trying to deflect blame on OP because really, how could you live with yourself if you abandoned your partner and unborn child, and then blocked all contact, did not check in near or after the due date, did not check in when you heard the news about the complications/baby's passing, then realized the gargantuan Difficult maybe, but that’s 8 hours farther from their abuser. HumdrumPrisoner OP responded: Back when my (23M) sister, Crystal (26F), was 16, she got pregnant by her ex-boyfriend, Andrew. She and Andrew decided to keep the pregnancy despite our parents' disapproval. Now she wants every last one of your family to tell you that her fee fee's are hurt from having her behavior be put on display for her to view from. But I would pay for college if she at least tried to form a bond with my family because she created this situation with her attitude. And all that his "anger" is, is a giant display of guilt. I (20F) have been planning my wedding to Micheal (21M) for the past 3 years. AITA for telling my sister that she's being a disloyal and terrible daughter for getting a hotel room with her fiance? My (28M) family is very traditional. She and my dad stalk and harass us. Spending time with them both is one of my favorite things and she's an awesome person. Including how she judged all of his ex's for getting into the exact situation she is in now, and how you actually were being supportive, you just weren't surprised because, well, why would you be after all the stuff she said to you in the past. In 2020 when Tory’s second wedding happened, I didn’t go. The people complaining need to step up before laying any blame on you. She is continuously nagging at me for not giving her a grandson, I know this may be harmless however my fiance has repeatedly told her that she already has a grandchild. AITA for telling my sister that she knew what she was getting when she settled for my cast-off ex? You can’t erase the truth, it will always find you. My wife and I have conflicting ideas on what that help should look like and my wife thinks my idea is callous and unhelpful. My ex, sister, and fiance knew each other when they were in high school. They sadly passed away, she was my I said I didn’t care and my little sister said she didn’t want to. Her husband's kids did not want to know my niece, and they rejected any kind of relationship and moved out as soon as they possibly could. It has been almost 7 years and we still get stuff in the mail and the occasional Absolutely he knew. She left to live with Andrew's family after our parents kicked her out. After reading the replies and talking with Todd, I'm going to have a conversation with my parents this weekend and set some boundaries. My wedding will be in a year. My parents knew I was pissed but had to “support” their daughter. She got uninvited from 4th if July by my mom bc she did it so much last year. But I didn’t fall for it. James was there with my sister and he was pissed and left early. Jul 22, 2024 · "Am I the asshole for telling my sister that just because she's a social worker it doesn't mean she always knows what's best for foster kids?" This was the question a Reddit user posted on the popular 'AITA' thread earlier this month, after a disagreement with her social sister over the best way to handle a difficult issue with her foster children. I also called her some not very pretty Oct 12, 2024 · HumdrumPrisoner OP responded:. I told my ex he needs to say something. I stuck to my word. Thank you. But here’s the real thing my sister aka my daughters stepmom had been telling my daughters how I was the one who broke up the marriage . This went on for several months before everyone met and moved in together, and then my sister married her husband. May’s father and I split shortly after she was born, and I met my now husband when she was about a year old. JowDow42. My goodness the parents knew, I'm sure of it, that they could easily be found out because of the proliferation of DNA tests out there (yes even 5 yrs ago) Yet the parents were Shady by not telling kids until they got CAUGHT. 4K votes, 3. Like my mom tried to hide my sisters real father- my sister didn’t know. My ex fling Anna (21f) is the sister of my best friend Josh (19m). She has been more than a sister to me, she is my best friend. I think cutting her out of your life sounds like a marvelous plan. I documented everything. I told her to consider herself down one sister and I told her I never wanted to see her again. She started crying. My sister was in her 30s when she saw. AITA? She asked what I meant, and I thought there was no point in lying so I just admitted I felt she upstaged me at my wedding. I could be a jerk for being too harsh and giving my opinion when she was venting Help keep the sub engaging! Don’t downvote assholes! Do upvote interesting posts! Click Here For Our Rules and Click Here For Our FAQ. Her head knew she was not at fault, but she was saying that not being able to give her husband "the gift of children", which is seen to most people as a wifely duty made her feel broken and not whole. original sound - Reddit Stories. The other day she was telling me about how one or her friends wasn’t a ‘girls girl’ because she slept with a guy my sister had an eye on and she feels depressed. Talk to my mother and she will wax poetic about my stepfather, who died in 2016. It was going to be my surprise wedding present so I didn’t dare tell her or anyone in her family my plans. AITA For Getting Married On My Sisters Anniversary r/redditonwiki • I [36F] declined to send my boyfriend [48M] nudes, so he accessed my personal email to see if he could find any in my sent messages to others Told my sister she knew what was going to happen when she named her late son after our grandfather. My parents then started giving me the AITA for telling my sister that she couldn’t attend my wedding after she copied my wedding dress? Yes, the title is misleading but let me explain. She may be like, "Oh fuck, I was just having fun stringing him on a bit and screwing with them, but now that OP has dumped him, he's going to be all up in my shit 24/7. I honestly don't know if she'll ever be in their good graces again and will only put up with her for my BIL and niece's sake. She'll tell you how generous and loving and kind he was. My sister is 30 and is married to a man who she, and our family, love. I tease my sister about my niece being a mini-me… because my sister raised both of us. So if she wants my help, she needs to attempt it. Jack's family have ceased their negative comments about my sister but she says that they're still pretty formal and distant towards her. My dream wedding is in October of this year and my sisters wedding is planned for the last day September. I said she's not my mom's daughter. So she threatened to use my PTSD to get my children removed to her care. Subreddit Announcements We are now in our late 20s. 4 She implied you think you're " too good for your home town " 5 She HAS to leave and you HAVE to reimburse me for gas. I got angry, and I told her that she had no right to anything that my grandmother left because she was the one who cut off contact, not us. Sep 14, 2024 · I told my sister that she knew what she was getting when she settled for my cast-off ex [Part 1] #reddit #redditposts #reelsfyp #ig #stories #redditstories #redditstorytimes #redditreadings AITA for telling my sister she isn’t a martyr and if I was her husband I would divorce her. I was so confused till she come home trying to come after me and I locked my room door. She wore quite a simple wedding dress but that was her choice! Edit #2: I never cheated or had an affair. AITA for telling my sister that she knew what she was getting when she settled for my EXWe’re dedicated to providing you with the highest quality story-readi She was ready to dish out her judgement not have it smack her in the face for knowing the state of what she was getting into. She went above and beyond to favor my younger purebred pale white sister. To be a little fair, I didn't report her to them. true. I research genealogy and found him accidentally through records. Both of us are close to our mom though. My goal was to protect her as best I could. She was screaming that I told her “now ex” she has kids which isn’t my business to tell which got him mad and that what I did is “child endangerment” because you shouldn’t mention kids to strangers and that she decides to tell people on her own time. Due to work and life circumstances, May primarily stayed with her father but visited us on the weekends when she was younger. My dad passed shortly after my sister's youngest 3rd birthday. I (43f) have two children, my daughter May is 21 and my son Luke is 17. How he always went to church and everyone loved him. May 19, 2025 · I am talking to the landlady, we will see how to move forward but for sure financially she will leave me broke, and about the mother, I don't know her well enough, I know she can't drive but I don't know much more. My sister called me later and yelled at me for upsetting James and trying to make him jealous to get his attention. Mom finally told my sister- my sister is 52! And mad. And if I ever tried to tell her how I think she my mom, I’d blubber too! Be happy OP! What a beautiful family you have, even if your mom is holding on too tight. My ex brings her during exchanges of our kids and she rushes out of the car with my kids. So we ended up moving in with Fred. I've reached the end of my patience with my sister so I'm going no contact with her. My own mother was mad she wasn't getting her way with me. My son was 14 when this happened and he pretty much took over taking care of his half brother and sister. You are wrong for not telling them. My niece's name first and middle is going to be legally changed to whatever Jack wants. She was stupid enough to write it down. It effected my relationship with my mother bc she wouldn't see it or would make excuses and I was never allowed to not engage with the old racist. AmItheAsshole ) submitted 3 hours ago by Lux_Tenebr1s to r/AmItheAsshole My sister moved in with the guy immediately. Lara was furious. One rule for all guests, family or no, is you can not sleep with your partner if you aren't married, no exceptions. . 2) I feel like I could have handled it better because she did lose her son Help keep the sub engaging! Don’t downvote assholes! Do upvote interesting posts! Click Here For Our Rules and Click Here For Our FAQ May 14, 2025 · She was told over and over by my sister that these two would adore her. Excuses of "she's a little old lady" are just that, harmful excuses. As someone who was raised by my sister also, I’m so happy for you. And my ex, when she had her anxiety attacks and severe depression 3 years ago, we agreed that she would be a housewife and have Quite a few people by that age are settled and stable on their lives, and sure, life happens, but not even trying is just odd to me. On Saturday my sister was married. my brother in law is getting married next year and I am so fucking excited to call his fiance my sister. Stepdad focused a lot of his time providing for us so I never got close to him but I am grateful for him. I am not sure all of what happened there, part of me doesn’t really want to know, but I do know her high school BF was there. And it still impacts me to this day. My baby girl (5), she's my best friend's daughter. You're NTA OP and Debbie can shove her attitude where the sun don't shine. She lived with them Whatever about my sister, I know her kids are not to blame for any of this and I know I treat the nieces and nephew's on my husband's side extremely well but I have never ever wanted to even meet my nieces and nephews and saying they are not my problem might make me not such a good person because they are innocent. vqkt bvr rmz hhgfc pokcvl rmabmub fpfh jxsy ahvds fqcyte